By MFJ Staff | Sources: Chargeflow, Juniper Research, and PR Newswire
Key takeaway: Merchants heading into the holiday peak should plan for higher chargeback volume. A Chargeflow and Juniper Research survey found that AI users win a higher share of disputes, but most merchants have not yet reached chargeback automation.
Chargeflow and Juniper Research reported on November 17, 2026 that 80% of surveyed merchants use AI in chargeback management. Only 11% have mostly or fully automated it. Chargeflow commissioned the survey. It covered 121 executives at U.S. and U.K. merchants with at least $100 million in annual gross merchandise value, so the findings describe large enterprise merchants rather than the market as a whole.
Merchants using AI reach a median chargeback win rate of 38%, compared with 27.75% for non-users. Sixty-five percent of respondents saw chargebacks rise over the past 18 months. Seventy-seven percent said chargebacks rise during the December holidays. Forty-three percent believe friendly fraud accounts for more than a quarter of their chargeback disputes. Juniper Research fielded the survey of chargeback management practices in September 2026, covering 80 U.S. and 41 U.K. respondents.
Chargeflow’s Data Lab studied about 3 million disputes across the last three peak seasons. The chargeback statistics show a shift in dispute reasons. During the 2025 Black Friday to Cyber Monday weekend, non-delivery claims made up 34.7% of chargebacks, up from 19.9% in a normal week. Fraud claims fell to 27.2% from 37.8% over the same period.
Dan Moshkovich, VP of Go-to-Market at Chargeflow, said most merchants “have added AI to a manual process.” He said AI helps merchants win more of the disputes they file. People still decide which disputes to file, so merchants end up fighting the same small share of eligible chargebacks. Juniper Research concluded that “while AI has delivered incremental improvements, it is not yet enough to meet enterprise expectations.”
Why it matters: Delivery disputes spike when order volume peaks, and they call for different evidence than card-fraud disputes. That shift matters for merchants building Black Friday fraud prevention plans. Shipping and delivery records may decide more cases than fraud signals. The survey also suggests that adding AI chargeback management tools to a manual process improves win rates modestly. Deciding which disputes are worth fighting still remains a human call for most merchants.












