• Latest

Merchants Should Be Wary of Payment Providers Getting into the Chargeback Guarantee Game

August 4, 2019 - Updated On October 7, 2019
A clear acrylic sign reading “Agentic Ready — Agentic Payments Testing Program” sits in front of a large Visa logo, representing Visa's testing initiative for AI-powered payments with merchants and payment service providers.

Visa Opens Agentic Ready, Its Agentic Payments Testing Program, to Merchants and PSPs

November 19, 2026
Veriff's Identity Fraud Report 2027 finds 62% of fraud-declined identities returned to the same business within an hour. Data covers Veriff users.

Veriff Identity Fraud Report Finds 62% of Fraud-Declined Identities Return Within an Hour

November 19, 2026
A miniature shopping cart and wooden payment-security blocks beside an infographic showing Chargeflow survey results: 80% of merchants use AI for chargeback management, while only 11% have automated the process.

Chargeflow Survey Finds 80% of Merchants Use AI for Chargeback Management While Only 11% Have Automated

November 18, 2026
A brass padlock and wooden blocks depicting a fraudster and a bank sit beside an Entrust report highlighting that account takeover fraud accounts for 52% of banking fraud, while deepfake attacks have increased by 165%, illustrated with rising blue bar charts.

Entrust Report Finds Account Takeover Fraud at 52% of Banking Fraud as Deepfake Attacks Rise 165%

November 18, 2026
A Sumsub fraud report displayed between two wooden blocks showing global fraud declining by 28% and deepfake fraud increasing by 31%, illustrated with downward and upward arrows against a world map background.

Sumsub Report Finds Global Fraud Down 28% While Deepfake Fraud Rises 31%

November 18, 2026
A Visa fraud report displaying a 62% increase in fraud incidents, with a rising bar chart, payment card, and padlock symbolizing growing third-party fraud risks and AI-enabled financial crime.

Visa Report Flags Third-Party Fraud Risk as Incidents Rise 62% and AI-Enabled Fraud Scales

November 18, 2026
Mastercard First-Party Trust program expands into Europe, represented by the Mastercard logo beside the European Union flag, symbolizing stronger payment security and collaboration to combat friendly fraud.

Mastercard Brings First-Party Trust Friendly Fraud Program to Europe

November 17, 2026
Silver handcuffs beside Bitcoin coins and a U.S. Department of Justice folder, with a prominent “$400 Million in Crypto Theft” headline, representing the DOJ's disruption of a North Korean deepfake cryptocurrency theft scheme.

DOJ Disrupts North Korean FaceStealer Deepfake Scheme Tied to $400 Million in Crypto Theft

November 17, 2026
A shopper authorizes a secure payment using a fingerprint scanner beside a bank card and shopping packages, while a glowing digital shopping cart and checkmark represent OpenAI's ChatGPT Wallet enabling AI agents to complete purchases on users' behalf.

OpenAI Launches ChatGPT Wallet to Let AI Agents Check Out for Shoppers

November 16, 2026
A black Rain single-use payment card displayed beside a secure digital Agent Vaults interface, illustrating how AI agents can make controlled payments using single-use cards with spending limits and security protections.

Rain Launches Agent Vaults With Single-Use Cards for AI Agent Payments

November 16, 2026
A judge’s gavel hovers above its sound block beside Visa and Mastercard payment cards and merchant receipts in a courtroom setting. The graphic highlights the November 16 final approval hearing for the swipe-fee settlement affecting approximately 12 million U.S. merchants.

Visa and Mastercard Swipe Fee Settlement Heads to Final Approval Hearing Nov. 16

November 13, 2026
A robotic arm places an oversized red coat into a shopping basket, while a balance scale holds two payment cards on opposite sides of a receipt, symbolizing AI shopping mistakes and the dispute over who bears financial responsibility.

Who Pays When an AI Shopping Agent Buys the Wrong Thing? Payment Firms Split on Liability

November 12, 2026
  • Contribute
  • Contact Us
  • About
  • Join Us
  • Advertise
Thursday, November 19, 2026
Merchant Fraud Journal
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Home
  • Articles
    • Chargebacks
    • Fraud Prevention
    • Influencer Insights
  • Resources
    • Recorded Webinars
    • Podcasts
    • Vendor Directory
    • eCommerce Fraud Reports
    • Training and Certifications
    • Jobs Board
    • Associations and Non-Profits
  • News
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Articles
    • Chargebacks
    • Fraud Prevention
    • Influencer Insights
  • Resources
    • Recorded Webinars
    • Podcasts
    • Vendor Directory
    • eCommerce Fraud Reports
    • Training and Certifications
    • Jobs Board
    • Associations and Non-Profits
  • News
No Result
View All Result
Merchant Fraud Journal
No Result
View All Result

Merchants Should Be Wary of Payment Providers Getting into the Chargeback Guarantee Game

Last Updated on October 7, 2019 by merchantfraudjournal

No one could have foreseen the scope and scale of the eCommerce fraud prevention problem. From the beginning of online stores, unscrupulous actors began to target unsuspecting, hardworking merchants. Unfortunately, it appears that even if online commerce sparked a revolution in how businesses connect with consumers, it did nothing to curb the darker impulses of human nature.

Everyone hopes the day will come when no eCommerce fraud solution is needed. But while we wait for that day (check back next week maybe?), we’ve also seen a revolution in the good work being done by talented and dedicated fraud specialists to protect merchants against thieves. It’s thanks to these people that fraud prevention solutions made huge strides over the last decade.

Merchants around the world benefit from the recent improvements in rules planning, sophisticated AI machine learning, and human intelligence. Over the past year, however, payment providers have begun rolling out their own solutions — offering a critical service that allows the online payments ecosystem to thrive. That will increase penetration into riskier markets and products — but it also poses huge risks that need to be addressed.

The Promise and Perils of Payment Provider Chargeback Guarantee Solutions

Merchants turn to fraud prevention vendors for two reasons. One, is the need to protect their revenues from the ill-effects of fraud. But equally important is that merchants want a simple, easy-to-understand solution. There is a big learning curve for merchants in the fraud prevention space. Most want clarity and serenity as much as a chargeback guarantee.

On the face of it, payment providers starting to offer a native fraud solution is great news. Their brand recognition inspires confidence. For example, merchants the world over already use and trust PayPal. And that’s just the start. Their ubiquity means they process a huge number of transactions and are sophisticated technological actors, comfortable with collecting and analyzing data to make improvements for end-users. In addition, they can provide a “one-stop shop” that can make for a seamless payments experience.

And yet, there are a ton of negative potential consequences that should give merchants pause. Payment providers are in the business of collecting fees on transactions — not fraud prevention. In-house innovation is likely to be rare, leaving shops vulnerable to changing eCommerce fraud trends. A solution at the payment provider level also risks lulling merchants into complacency and a false sense of security. After all, who needs to take the time to understand the impact of fraud prevention on their business, if they know Stripe is already taking care of it?

What’s Needed Is Education, Diligence…and a Human Touch

These problems have (at least) four solutions.

First, vendors should do more to emphasize their fraud-specific experience and technological expertise. The average merchant still views fraud as “simple” chargeback prevention. Massive investment is needed to explain the technological, strategic, and tactical innovations necessary to prevent theft by increasingly sophisticated cyber-criminals — innovations payment providers are unlikely to fully commit to. Moreover, the potentially devastating impact an over-focus on chargeback prevention can bring via false positive declines needs to be better communicated to the market.

Second, payment providers must be transparent about their business model. A traditional chargeback guarantee solution only makes money on approved orders — a practice that keeps their business interests aligned with merchants’. In contrast, payment providers take a fee for every transaction, a potential incentive to not guarantee risky orders (but still profit on the transaction fee) while charging fraud prevention fees on safe orders. They must be proactive about ensuring their practices actually provide value to merchants, and provide full visibility so verification is possible.

Third, merchants must commit to doing their homework. No two businesses are the same. It might be that for a SMB just getting started in an industry with relatively little fraud, a solution at the payment provider level is sufficient. But for an equally small company selling an innovative product with high resale value, it will most likely be worth the time to choose a third-party fraud prevention solution. Merchants must understand their needs and be honest about what it takes to meet them.

Finally, the impact of eCommerce fraud needs to be humanized. Massive data breaches at gigantic global companies like the one that recently struck Capital One make for great headlines. They also serve to dehumanize the issue of fraud, making it less likely merchants will take it seriously (until it’s too late). Both merchants and vendors should focus more on the human impact of fraud —less time for founders to create visionary products, stressed employees, and even potential layoffs. Many businesses still do not fully realize the impact fraud can have beyond their bottom line.

Payment providers have a lot to offer the eCommerce fraud prevention space. But to avoid becoming a cure worse than the disease, they must integrate themselves into the existing ecosystem — not seek to replace it.

~The Editorial Board

Tags: Chargeback Guarantee
TweetShareSend
Previous Post

Pearson Data Breach Compromises 100,000+ Students

Next Post

Influencer Insights: An Interview with Arcus FI

Next Post

Influencer Insights: An Interview with Arcus FI

Search:

No Result
View All Result

Our Latest Reports

Fraud Trends Report

Consumer Payments Survey Report

Fraud Prevention Tactics that Enable Exceptional Customer Experience

ATO Fraud In Retail Report

3 Ways a Unified Chargeback Management and Fraud Platform Increases Revenue

Digital Trust And Safety Report: Combating the Evolving Complexities of Payment Fraud

On-Demand Webinars

New Trends in The Payments Ecosystem

Balancing Customer Experience and Fraud Prevention: What’s the Secret?

Stopping Fraud Across the Customer Lifecycle

Addressing Payment Fraud and the Customer Experience in 2022

 

Quick Navigation

  • Home
  • News
  • Join Us
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Contribute
  • Privacy Policy

Privacy Policy

Our Privacy Policy
Our Terms of Use

Resources

  • Articles
  • eCommerce Fraud Reports
  • eCommerce Fraud Webinars
  • Associations and Non-Profits
  • Podcasts
  • Vendor Directory
  • Chargeflow – AI Chargeback Management

Featured Vendors

  • Signifyd
  • TransUnion
  • PayRetailers
  • Spotrisk
  • CB-ALERT
  • Chargeflow
  • Corepay
  • AtData
No Result
View All Result
  • About Merchant Fraud Journal
    • Interested in Contributing or Guest Posting to Merchant Fraud Journal?
    • Merchant Fraud Journal Editorial Guidelines
  • Advertise on Merchant Fraud Journal
  • Articles
    • Chargebacks
    • Fraud Prevention
    • Influencer Insights
  • Contact Us
  • Download Addressing Payment Fraud and Customer Experience Report
  • Download Chargebacks Consumer Survey Report 2022
  • Download Evolving Complexities of Payment Fraud Report
  • Download Fraud Prevention Tactics that Enable Exceptional Customer Experiences Report
  • Download Merchant Fraud Journal 2023 Fraud Trends Report
  • Download Merchant Fraud Journal 2024 Fraud Trends Report
  • Download Merchant Fraud Journal Generative AI Fraud Prevention Checklist for SMBs
  • Download Quantifying the Challenge of Friendly Fraud: Your Post-purchase Strategy for the Future
  • Download the 2020 Chargeback and Representment Report
  • Download the 2020 Merchant Fraud Journal Vendor Guide
  • Download the 2021 Fraud Trends Report
  • Download the 2022 Fraud Trends Report
  • Download the 2023 Consumer Payment Trends Report
  • Download the 3 Ways a Unified Chargeback Management and Fraud Platform Increases Revenue Report
  • Download the MFJ 2022 Customer Experience Report
  • Download the MFJ ATO in Retail Report
  • Home
  • Home Elementor
  • Job Dashboard
  • Join The Merchant Fraud Journal Community
  • Merchant Fraud Journal Advertising Agreement
  • Merchant Fraud Journal Advertising Agreement – Signifyd
  • MFJ Fraud Trends Report Giveaway
  • News
  • Post a Job
  • Privacy Policy
  • Resources
    • #9978 (no title)
    • 2020 Chargeback Representment Guide for Merchants
    • 2020 Vendor Guide
    • 2023 Consumer Payments Survey Report
    • 3 Ways a Unified Chargeback Management and Fraud Platform Increases Revenue
    • 8 Fraud Prevention Training and Certifications: A 2026 Guide
    • Addressing Payment Fraud and the Customer Experience in 2022
    • Associations and Non-Profits
    • ATO Fraud In Retail Report
    • Balancing Customer Experience and Fraud Prevention: What’s the Secret?
    • Chargebacks Consumer Survey Report 2022
    • Digital Trust & Safety: Combating the Evolving Complexities of Payment Fraud
    • eCommerce Fraud Reports
    • eCommerce Fraud Webinars
    • Fraud Prevention Tactics that Enable Exceptional Customer Experiences
    • How to Build a Recession Proof Chargeback Prevention Strategy
    • How to Reduce Customer Friction During Holiday Sales Season
    • How to Stop Fraud During the 2022 Holiday Season
    • Jobs Board
    • Merchant Fraud Journal 2023 Fraud Trends Report
    • Merchant Fraud Journal’s Fraud Trends 2020 Report
    • Merchant Fraud Journal’s Generative AI Fraud Prevention Report: A Checklist for SMB Companies
    • Merchant Fraud Journal’s Fraud Trends 2021 Report
    • Merchant Fraud Journal’s Fraud Trends 2022 Report
    • MFJ’s 2022 Customer Experience Report
    • Podcasts
    • Prevent High-Velocity Fraud Attacks During the 2021 Holiday Season
    • Quantifying the Challenge of Friendly Fraud: Your Post-purchase Strategy for the Future
    • Stopping Fraud Across the Customer Lifecycle
    • The surprisingly easy way to secure your payment data, reduce your risk, and win the war on ecommerce fraud
    • Vendor Directory
    • Webinar – Addressing Payment Fraud and the Customer Experience in 2022
    • Webinar – Mitigating Fraud and Risk on the ACH Network
    • Win January Chargeback Disputes
  • Subscribed
  • Terms and Conditions

© 2026 Merchant Fraud Journal

Not enough quota to unlock this post
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?